SCOTUS Boulder Climate Lawsuit Arguments
The Supreme Court heard oral arguments Monday in Boulder's climate lawsuit against Exxon Mobil and Suncor Energy.
DEVELOPING TIMELINE
First Report Oct 6: The Supreme Court heard oral arguments Monday in Boulder County's climate lawsuit against Suncor and ExxonMobil.
Oct 7: Justices Jackson and Sotomayor seek escape hatch on jurisdiction
DIFFERENT FOCUS
New Republic and NPR Politics emphasized Corporate Accountability for Climate Harm; Fox News Politics and Washington Free Beacon emphasized Liberal Justices Seek Jurisdictional Exit.
LEFT FOCUS
- ▸Most justices appeared more skeptical of the fossil fuel companies than of Boulder's legal position. — New Republic
- ▸Boulder argues the companies knowingly lied about climate harms to their community for decades. — New Republic
- ▸The case has repercussions beyond climate, touching on broader local-government accountability powers. — NPR Politics
RIGHT FOCUS
- ▸Conservative legal expert Carrie Severino of JCN told Fox News that Justices Jackson and Sotomayor were seeking an 'escape hatch' on jurisdiction. — Fox News Politics
- ▸Success for Boulder could force oil companies to pay billion-dollar fines for floods, droughts, and heat waves. — Washington Free Beacon
- ▸The Trump Department of Justice participated as a party in oral arguments alongside the energy companies. — Washington Free Beacon